Friday, 28 January 2011

Google flushes its Property Portal down the loo mmmmmm

Google flushes its property portal down the loo.

After much media fanfare, Google appears to have abandoned its ambitions in the property portal space less than two years after first experimenting with the idea.

The search giant announced last night that it will remove property listings from Google Maps where this option is currently available in the US, Australia, New Zealand, the UK and Japan.

As part of the change, Google is phasing out the facility for agents and developers to upload properties directly to its classified site, Google Base which is being replaced by a new service named Google Shopping.

Unprofitable business model

In its official statement Google cites low usage, fierce competition and high infrastructure costs as the main reasons for its change of heart:

“In part due to low usage, the proliferation of excellent property-search tools on real estate websites, and the infrastructure challenge posed by the impending retirement of the Google Base API (used by listing providers to submit listings), we’ve decided to discontinue the real estate service”

Shortly after launch, we outlined the hurdles Google had to overcome to succeed in its real estate venture. What has become clear is that it failed to find answers to two key questions:

How do you increase Adwords revenue at the same time as promoting your own portal?

It could not square the circle of sending searchers to a site (Google maps) where the adverts are less prominent and therefore users are less profitable than in the main search results.

• How do you build a cost-effective infrastructure that presents clean, up-to-date listings in a compelling way for the property searcher?

Google cites low usage as a key reason for its exit but the main reason for failure is it never prominently promoted its listings within the main search results.

It tested this but failed to find a way to make the economics stake up so its real estate results always remained relatively hidden.

Google also arguably underestimated the time, skill and resources it requires to run a modern-day, cutting-edge property portal. If the revenues had been there, it could have bought in the expertise but the numbers just did not stack up.

Limitations of map-based search

One factor which many, including Global edge, failed to anticipate is the limitations of map-based search. A number of prominent portal owners have recently cited tests that show most consumers prefer a list of properties to quickly compare images and property features to searching on a map.

Ultimately, Google could not provide a consumer experience comparable with the best portals, in the markets in which it operated, at a cost that made the excercise worth while.

Portal owners around the world will be smiling today. It's not as good news though for agents, as Google's departure will only discourage further new entrants and raise the price of lead generation over the longer term.



MRBlogger said...

Hi All,

I just want to share the great new investment opportunity I have found.

Every person who would like to make a move into an investment opportunity - repossessed houses are the key. This is the easiest and most cost effective way to start your dream in a new house. repossessed houses are often purchased for 50% or less of their current market value! Thus, making it a great opportunity to step into the property market as an investor. repossessed houses are found everywhere, but one of the easiest ways are going to repossessed houses, and searching for the house that best fits your needs.

Happy Hunting!

Gareth said...

Google test so many applications, and so many are great - and many are free. Maybe the Property Portal will be revived at some point in an improved format?

Kuba Jewgieniew said...

LOL - that's funny.

Here's my point. That result is wildly irrelevant but still the algo picked it. Yes, the query is crazy long tail and not likely to be anyone's ranking goal. But why would the algo weight things that way at all, even in an edge case?

Cape Coral Rental Management said...

It is not hard to see from perusing your other post comments that this is a subject which brings out many arguments discussing this topic. I guess it is always good to meet fellow opinionated people! Just one more thing I added this page to my Twitter favorites.

Cavite Web Design said...

I am , I bit the past that my offer to contribute to the due recognition , but especially me, made ??publishing a feeling . it is to absorb a weblog post is . I'm back again, websites , though re- discovered after one of the Web site's regular readers to have. I Your two their two wildly to interpret was nevertheless mentioned , I do anything accept some say I can not ! almost certainly return

Baltimore Nightlife said...

Attractive part of content. I just stumbled upon your blog and in accession capital to claim that I get actually loved account your blog posts.